British Theatre Guide logo
 
The Edinburgh Fringe

 

Links

Articles

News

Reviews

Amateur Theatre

Contact

Other Resources

 

Fringe 2002 Reviews (17)

Catherine Lamm, our New York correspondent, dancer, theatre director and occasional theatre journalist, reviews some not-terribly-good shows. She comments on these one star shows:

Sometimes the kindest and most encouraging thing is not to review but just to warn. Actors, writers, directors and producers involved in these shows that fail so totally are advised: learn, move on, and do try again. But learn.

Things missing and sorely lacking in these productions are well written scripts with solid foundations and something universal to say about the human condition; actors who can make language and characters their own, and justify the actions; directors with clear, strong, and singular views of a whole production and producers who can rally support and know when things are going way off track.

Beautiful Thing by About Turn at Rocket @ South Bridge never clearly defined or focused itself. The cast, which covers two generations, are played by actors nearly all the same age. And the characters are so superficially drawn as to be laughable and cliché-ed. The play is about two boys exploring their budding sexuality and homosexuality.

A Midsummer Night's Rock by Bury Lawn Productions at C is another show cast with amateurs. Although the show is capably chopped up and Will holds up, the music is spartan, the singing and dancing embarassing and the "acting" is devoid of any talent save for Bongani Bhebhe (as Bottom) who bristles with potential.

The Tragedian by the Prodigal Theatre Company at Smirnoff Underbelly is the insulting and excessively overindulgent work of what would appear to be some professionals. The fault is not necessarily with the unengaging solo performer. A strong director might be able to make the unsympathetic character of Edmund Keene into one that the audience cares about.

First Love by Act Provocateur International at the Zoo Venue seems to want to do nothing more that shock and confuse the audience. For a "dance" or "movement" piece it is far too random and improvisational. For a theatre piece the script is practically non-existant for as many words as it has.

Painting With Colour by Boundless at the Pleasance Dome is too fractured to follow. It is supposed to explore the relationships and emotions between an artist & model and an actor & dresser. It only comes together near the end when Kaveh Rahnama, the sole male dancer and juggler, breaks out on his own.

Fantasy by Discovery Dance Theatre at C, Chambers Street, is a play gone wrong. It starts by examing in a superficial way the relationship of four school chums, following them as their friendships deepen or they become estranged with maturity. A few clever mimes dot thoughout and this would be satisfying piece aimed at children but it changes halfway into the dark territory of rape and substance abuse. Two theatre productions collide and the production does not survive.

Taboo at the Gilded Balloon Teviot. Not Shocking! Not Provocative. Not theatre! And not Funny!

Index -- Next

 

 

©Peter Lathan 2002