British Theatre Guide logo
 
The Edinburgh Fringe

 

Links

Articles

News

Reviews

Amateur Theatre

Contact

Other Resources

 

 

Fringe 2005 Reviews (23)

The Odd Couple
By Neil Simon
Assembly Hall
****

The forty-year old Odd Couple needs no introduction: on stage and on film it has been popular throughout its life and has even spawned a female version, also written by Neil Simon. It has been produced by rep companies and amateur societies the length and breadth of the country (and, no doubt, throughout the US too). To borrow a jazz expression, it's a "standard".

Audiences know what they's going to get and the only question is, How well will it be performed?

The publicity - one might almost say hype - for this particular production by Guy Masterson has centred around the fact that comedians Alan Davies (Felix) and Bill Bailey (Oscar) play the odd couple of the title, but that does the show less than justice, for there is a cast of eight who have a significant part to play in the play. These other characters are also played by comedians (except for actresses Katherine Jakeways and Lizzie Roper, who actually does do some stand-up in addition to her mainly TV and voice-over work). All turn in good performances and, although the two Pigeon sisters are the ones the audience will most likely remember, that's because Simon gives them some of the best lines of all the supports.

It is, however, the arrival onstage of, first, Bill Bailey and then Alan Davies which the audience is most looking forward to and, although it didn't happen on the day I was there, I certainly got the feeling that they wanted to applaud the stars' appearance.

They do give a good account of themselves, with Bailey a bit ahead on points, slipping comfortably into the role of the slobby Oscar. Davies gets the anally-retentive Felix well too, but that accent! It wasn't exactly mid-Atlantic, more Essex man who has spent a bit of time watching old American black and white movies.

I was doubtful that it would be worthwhile reviving the play, thinking it has been done to death over the years, but I am a convert!

Peter Lathan

The Red Shoes
After Hans Christian Andersen, adapted by Stephe Harrop
Touch My Toes Theatre
C Central
**(*)

This production attempts to unite the allegory of the classic Hans Christian Andersen fairy tale with a story set in a contemporary war zone but the narrative line is a bit confused and not always easy to follow.

Described as a physical theatre piece, it does have some striking images but the physicality is generally on a fairly basic, dance-related, level.

There was plenty of energy and commitment from the cast but the lack of narrative clarity meant tha,t for me at any rate, it didn't really work.

Peter Lathan

Tropea: Couch Potatoes' Paradise
Laroque Dance Company/Helene Weinzierl
AuroraNova@St Stephens
***

There is a whimsical humour about the set up to Tropea. A rather trashy and bourgeois 'hausfrau' is the couch potato on an overstuffed sofa in a cluttered lounge with fluffy slippers and remote control ready to zap. The irony is that she is on the screen while the TV programmes she is watching are happening live on the stage. Footballers and celebrities are joined by holiday makers with flippers, snorkels and plastic sharks, chat show hosts, and political commentary. This is quick change theatre and the dancers have all their costumes to hand on a rack onstage.

This is nimble choreography in which movement approximates more or less to real life actions and it is the dancing that saves an otherwise bland production that really doesn't go anywhere or live up to its initial promise. It is a pleasant performance, charming in places but perhaps too gentle for my own tastes.

Jackie Fletcher

Next page - - - Index

 

 

©Peter Lathan 2005