British Theatre Guide logo
 
The Edinburgh Fringe

 

Links

Articles

News

Reviews

Amateur Theatre

Contact

Other Resources

 

 

Fringe 2006 Reviews (14)

True West
By Sam Shepard
Assembly Rooms
***

Edinburgh has become the home of a new phenomenon, comedians setting themselves up as actors, often to occupy their days prior to late nights telling jokes in no longer smoky clubs.

One of the most successful cross-over artists is Phil Nicoll, who last year won the Stage Best Actor Award. Now, with the same director, Maggie Inchley, he joins three other stand-ups for an extreme comedy from Sam Shepard.

Nicoll plays a straight-laced film screenwriter Austin, who is house-sitting while his mother holidays in Alaska. Things go wrong when his kooky brother Lee - Tom Stade giving a well-judged portrayal - arrives fresh from three months in the desert.

The ever-threatening Lee, who has something of a messianic look, decides that his story would make a good film and enlists his brother's writing skills.

To general surprise, Dave Johns' bigshot producer Saul goes for the unknown writer's contemporary Western, much to the chagrin of his ditched brother.

The play concludes with the arrival of something like sanity in the form of the men's returning mother, played by Laura Brook using an accent that needs a lot more work.

With its mix of human foible and madness and chalk and cheese brothers, this is characteristic Shepard. The comedians take on their new roles pretty well, though whether this trend and its implication that comedians can act as well as those trained for years has not yet been fully proven.

Philip Fisher

Bodies In Transit
By Nina Larissa Bassett
Mucca Divina
Traverse
***(*)

Despite the pains the programme goes to in explaining how much research went into Bodies in Transit, in the end there's only so much one can say about the sex trafficking of women from Eastern Europe to the west, and this play doesn't exactly cover new ground. At the same time, Bassett's script is well-crafted and avoids sensationalism.

The staging uses various physical theatre techniques to portray Lola (Iben Hendel Philipsen) and her emotional struggle/journey. This is an interesting decision on Philipsen and director Lars Henning's parts, as at times the transition is so jarring that it forces the viewer to disassociate from events. Trying to overlook this proves difficult as Philipsen ricochets through her 'nineteen characters,' since without her changing her voice or much about her physicality, the only hints that one character has gone and another arrived are the jolts as she flings herself from one side of a conversation to the other, or in the extremely stylized hand gestures she uses to signify each character. It's clear, but distracting.

At the end, one is left with a strange feeling - not precisely empty, not precisely full, and not really sure what to make of Lola's sad tale. The play seems to suggest a problem without offering the audience any idea of how it can be solved - like Lola, we are left feeling like trapped witnesses to an atrocious set of circumstances, without any clear way of getting out.

Rachel Lynn Brody

Alun Cochrane - Introducing an Introduction to Alun Cochrane's Imagination
Gilded Balloon Teviot
****

Alun Cochrane did an excellent job of hosting Best of the Fest last year, dealing very well with the aftermath of some loud objections from a couple of audience members to Richard Herring's unfunny obscenities and attempts to shock.

His own show this year is based on the premise that he believes himself to have no imagination and is trying to develop it. In order to do this, he has created The Unicorn Sketch, which is so imaginative it will blow our minds.

Cochrane creates a very amiable character on stage, like a friendly northern bloke who might start chatting to you in a pub. He appears to be perfectly genuine about everything he says, as though he is telling you the absolute truth as he sees it. He doesn't ask for much in life - to him, wearing odd socks is a bit exciting and sexy - but he likes to be straight and truthful about everything. However he does tend to get easily diverted and will sometimes start to tell you about one thing and then go off onto a completely different train of thought. In fact, if you're unlucky, he might get so diverted with his list of dislikes that he might completely forget to do The Unicorn Sketch, with effects that make the helicopter in Miss Saigon look rubbish.

Cochrane's set is slick, polished and very funny, and he has a great relationship with the audience on stage. He is well worth a look.

David Chadderton

Next page - - - Index

 

 

©Peter Lathan 2006