British Theatre Guide logo
 
The Edinburgh Fringe

 

Links

Articles

News

Reviews

Amateur Theatre

Contact

Other Resources

 

 

Fringe 2007 Reviews (40)

England
By Tim Crouch
Traverse @ the Fruitmarket Gallery
*****

After he performed An Oak Tree at the Traverse two years ago and My Arm two years before that, Tim Crouch's latest play, England, is a semi-promenade piece at a small art gallery near to Edinburgh's main railway station in the heart of the city.

The narrator tells us about the gallery and the current exhibition and about the importance of art in general and tells us that "my boyfriend" knows more about art and how to explain it and has quite a collection of important pieces of his own. However our storyteller is ill, but the power of money manages to buy a new heart and a few more years of life. On the other side of the world, the recipient of the new heart has travelled to thank the widow of its donor and to give her a special present, but in return gets a very different side to the story of how the heart was obtained to the official version.

Much of this story is pieced together by the spectator from the fragments of information scattered through the text and none of it is told in any conventional storytelling way. In the first half, the two performers, Crouch himself with Hannah Ringham, move around the upstairs gallery as guides but both apparently speaking as the main character in the narrative, who is never specified as being male or female. For the second act, the audience is seated in one of the small downstairs galleries in a more conventional theatre configuration, and the two performers speak the words of our main character after the operation and the translator at the meeting with the widow of the heart donor Hassam (although each performer doesn't always play the same person in the scene).

In the hands of many performers and writers, this could turn out to be pretentious nonsense, but Crouch has produced a piece that is not always easy to watch but is absolutely fascinating and draws the audience into its stories even when they aren't always entirely sure where they are being taken. For most of the time, Crouch delivers his lines with a big, benevolent smile that is quite infectious, and Ringham beams around at the spectators like a child who is pleased to have their attention.

The first act mostly consists of scattered information that leaves its audience to assemble its own viewpoint and at times is quite funny. The second act is extremely moving and though-provoking, leaving images to haunt you and make you think for quite some time afterwards.

This unique practitioner has once again produced a unique piece of theatre that is well worth seeing.

David Chadderton

Scarborough
By Fiona Evans
Northern Firebrand
Assembly Rooms
*****

Considering that its running time is under 45 minutes, Scarborough is an amazingly intricate and multi-layered drama.

The storyline is not original but the staging and writing certainly are. The audience of around 25 is crammed into a seedy Scarborough B&B bedroom together with two lovers.

They are 16 year old Daz (James Baxter) and a woman almost twice his age, Holly Atkins as Lauren. Ignoring the obvious difference in age and outlooks, their primary problem is that she is his PE teacher.

This kind of story hits the tabloid front pages fairly regularly and they always have a prurient field day attacking the evil teacher. Fiona Evans makes us consider the human side to the stories.

Lauren is engaged to a man a generation older than she is, Geoff who used to be her swimming coach. That would usually beg its own questions. She is genuinely torn between the two men but knows in her heart of hearts that an illegal relationship will never prosper.

Daz is both sensitive and immature, but as he says, he is supposed to be the latter. As one might expect, he is more bullish, both about the future of the affair and the odds of avoiding detection. Characteristically, at times though, he is more interested in his new Nintendo than his lover.

Deborah Bruce's beautifully-acted production is really claustrophobic, the performers tripping over audience members and they in turn, feeling embarrassingly close to both the high jinks and the explosive anger, never better than when Lauren believes that the Headmaster is in town.

Fiona Evans has already won a Fringe First for Scarborough and it is well deserved. This small play, which is performed three times every afternoon, is both insightful and moving. Get in before word gets around. This will be a sell out show.

Philip Fisher

Venus as a Boy
Adapted by Tam Dean Burn from the novel by Luke Sutherland
Traverse 2
****

As one has come to expect from any show with the National Theatre of Scotland imprimatur, Venus as a Boy is a highly professional and thought provoking solo play.

In fact, there is a second performer as the show's progenitor, Luke Sutherland, provides musical accompaniment to Tam Dean Burn. He does so using electric guitar and violin, plucking and bowing both to generate an unearthly sound reminiscent of Jesus and Mary Chain.

We are asked to accept that what we see and hear was contained on a series of minidisks delivered randomly to black Orcadian Luke Sutherland by a skinhead in Soho.

The tale is a sad one. Cupid (or Desiree) grew up on Orkney and never fitted in. Where the rest of his school companions liked boy things, he preferred the company of girls - and their clothing.

The few friends that he made suffered for their friendship and gradually, he moved further and further South, getting beaten along the route to Soho, where he was taken up as a transvestite whore by sinister Romanian fascist Radu.

Life in Radu's brothel seemed bearable, improving when transsexual Wendy turned up and love blossomed. Nothing lasts and Cupid's lack of trust and Wendy's of faithfulness led to a bitter break, with our hero condemned to sex-slavery. Bizarrely, he then found final love with a vicious skinhead, whose head he turned.

Tam Dean Burn gives a wonderfully sensitive but humorous performance as this colourful character. He eventually dons all of the accoutrements of a golden boy without a Midas touch in a spectacular finale to a touching portrayal of an outsider.

Philip Fisher

Next page - - - Index

 

 

©Peter Lathan 2007