British Theatre Guide logo
 
The Edinburgh Fringe

 

Links

Articles

News

Reviews

Amateur Theatre

Contact

Other Resources

 

 

Fringe 2007 Reviews (52)

I, Lear
By Andrew Jones and Ciaran Murtagh
The Black Sheep
Assembly @ St George's West
***

The Black Sheep have decided that Fringe theatregoers will enjoy a little escapism with a show that ridicules theatre. This strange-looking duo take snippets from many genres and send them up, before bringing the whole together in an extended sketch version of William K. (sic) Shakespeare's tale of a foolish old man and a mannish fool.

In the early sketches, we get everything from Antigone to Tennessee Williams, Chekhov to Dickens and a rather subtle Alan Bennett as the boys have a lot of fun, generally demonstrating the shouting school of dramatic acting. They are at their best in a wonderful spoof of Sherlock Holmes in which Watson is even denser than usual.

The show is also educational as the value of marmite, squirty cream, humps and Lord Lloyd Webber are more than ably demonstrated.

The undoubted highlight though is the Lear, which somehow catches the spirit of the original, while getting more laughs from this critic than the whole of the rest put together.

Philip Fisher

Tir Nan Og
By Dave Anderson
Oran MorE! at Assembly
Assembly Rooms
****

This sister piece to A Walk in the Park, which involves the same company, is a real delight. The pleasure is in seeing a packed mini-musical beautifully performed by a team of four all of whom contribute in different ways.

The plot isn't always easy to divine but it follows the mythical journey of a drunken sailor around the world. Her final destination is the land of Tir Nan Og, a paradise.

Pauline Knowles sings and acts her way into the role of a drunken sailor who is like a latter-day Jonah. She is forever in trouble through a charming 45 minutes packed with a wide variety of music that favours jazz but also includes a jaunty sea shanty.

All four company members sing but the main vocal support for Miss Knowles comes from Jennifer Rhodes, who has a lovely voice and also plays the flute, while the versatile Alan Tall plays at least half a dozen musical instruments.

Writer Dave Anderson who composed the music for last year's National Theatre of Scotland sensation Black Watch, joins them from the keyboards.

Rosie Kellagher's production looks attractive and fits a vast amount into a short time, showcasing its talented team and combining gentle humour with enjoyable music and some touching moments.

Philip Fisher

Dai (Enough)
Written and performed by Iris Bahr
Bernie Kukoff, Jonathan Pollard, Jon Cutler in association with Paul Lucas Productions
Pleasance
*****

Iris Bahr's outstanding solo performance touches the marrow of the Israeli multicultural society, embracing the humour that helps the country face the often tragic reality.

The scene is set in a Tel Aviv café, where Bahr amusingly portrays the British-Syrian journalist, Christiane Saloniki, reporting a piece on Israeli society minutes before a loud bang and total blackout put an abrupt end to a brief encounter.

The café is the backdrop to ten other characters, with a freeze frame of an eerie loud bang from an almost tangible yet invisible suicide bomber, followed by a total blackout. The pain of that reality is astonishingly real.

Bahr moves seamlessly from one character to the next. Humour, accentuated gestures and monologues are delivered effortlessly with a vocabulary and an accent to match. We meet different characters, among whom there is Svetlana, a Russian prostitute who proudly confesses that for $50 only she managed to have forged her way to a 'Jewish ID' in order to work in Israel. There is also Alma Yalin, a caricature of an Israeli desperate to sound 'American' and keen to dismiss Israel as a 'third varld country' - who cannot understand why anyone would want to live 'in thees country'. Only in Israel on a visit to her sick mother, she cannot 'vait to get out'. Like all the others, she exits in a bang. There is Uzi, a Zionist and former general whose accent and body language are comically reminiscent of Ariel Sharon. (Uzi has lost a son in Lebanon). There is also Shuli, an orthodox West Bank settler from Queens who explains why the Jews have the right to the land of milk and honey. Her monologue makes the audience sit up and listen, bringing the listeners to the verge of a strange understanding, though not necessarily accepting her point of view. Finally, there is the sophisticated Nijma Aziz, a Palestinian Statistician, level-headed and liberal in her views. Her battle is not with the Israelis but with her son who has been radicalised by Islamic extremists. She agreed to meet her son in the very same coffee shop.

"Dai" is a Hebrew word which expresses exasperation and desire to put an end to a situation or a reality; it is in fact an plea to stop.

Bahr highlights the complex mixture of this rainbow of cultures which makes up so much of Israel. She also unmasks the human faces behind the statistics of the victims of suicide bombers by making them uncannily familiar. There is a silent thunder demanding in the name of all the living, regardless of background and religion or sexual inclination, that we all unite and say 'Enough' to the indiscriminate taking of innocent lives.

Rivka Jacobson

Next page - - - Index

 

 

©Peter Lathan 2007