British Theatre Guide logo
 
The Edinburgh Fringe

 

Links

Articles

News

Reviews

Amateur Theatre

Contact

Other Resources

 

 

Fringe 2008 Reviews (101)

Hostage
By Jenny Chapman
Tweed Theatre
Sweet ECA
*(*)

Following the story of a Scottish knight James Douglas, captured by Muslim extremists in 15th Century Spain, this play by Jenny Chapman is brought to the Festival after a successful local run. Taking the story of a captured Knight being ransomed against his government has many modern parallels but this play doesn't attempt to make them. Instead we are treated to a play that doesn't really know what to to with itself. The narrative is split between James in his darkened prison, being visited occasionally by his captor or by the local fundamental extremist ruler, both of whom torment him mentally and physically. The remainder of the action revolves around his betrothed Alison and her long struggle to raise the money to free him.

The actors try their hardest with the material and do quite well, but the same cannot be said for the wandering accents, including the Glaswegian twang on the Muslims which was not only distracting but occasionally downright amusing. The thick overplayed period dialogue from the monks and the healer woman were also unnecessarily distracting. However the most eye-rolling moment came from the dramatic 'down with the infidels' speech towards the end from the Muslim fundamentalist which was compounded by the dramatic B-movie spotlight highlighting him as he worked into a fervour. A wasted opportunity on what could have been an emotional and intelligent piece of theatre.

Graeme Strachan

Cure
Struck Dumb Theatre
Baby Belly
**

In a world gone mad, with cancer spreading like an epidemic through the people of Britain, a cure is what the people cry out for, but when it is discovered it turns out that the cure is worse than the disease itself. A good premise for a play, and would have made a fascinating piece of serious drama, but instead sadly instead we are given a featherweight farce which never entirely finds its feet.

To be honest, I'm not certain what the makers of this play were aiming for when they wrote this tale of a Britain lost to totalitarian ideals and capitalist nightmare. It manages to be everything and nothing at the same time. The story is clumsy but entertaining and it manages to be irreverent yet never particularly funny.

The cast are all exemplary but have little to work with and the characters themselves are varied enough to add flavour but at the same time make no sense at all in the story. Plausibly including an Irish Prime Minister, a fruit-addicted drug dealer and a psychotic Japanese schoolgirl in the same scene is an accomplishment in itself, yet why are none of the character's back stories ever filled in? With more than half of the story pertaining to the relationship between a nurse and the drug dealer, it might have made sense to explain why she capitulated to his demands without question throughout, but it never happens. As a result the whole is a mess, and despite drawing the attention for an hour, never manages to convince the audience that they should have bothered.

Graeme Strachan

Hamlet Episode
Daegu City Modern Dance Company
Rocket@Roxburghe Hotel
*****

There are plenty of reasons why the Daegu City Modern Dance Company is one of the most exciting events on the Fringe. Firstly, there are twenty-five dancers, elegant and athletic, graceful and robust, fluid and acrobatic, lyrical and dynamic. Then there are fabulous costumes: simple and stylish, colourful and sober, flowing and clinging. Add to that the moody lighting and the musical score, heightening the tensions and underscoring emotions. And a sublime choreography, a synergy of bodies that sends spirits soaring and senses reeling in a seamless fusion of movement styles.

Hamlet Episode is 60 minutes of pure and unadulterated excitement as bodies clash furiously, brush sensually, tumble athletically, touch tenderly and engage spiritually.

Wow! Wow! And again, wow!

Jackie Fletcher

Next page - - - Index

 

 

©Peter Lathan 2008