British Theatre Guide logo
 
The Edinburgh Fringe

 

Links

Articles

News

Reviews

Amateur Theatre

Contact

Other Resources

 

 

Fringe 2008 Reviews (76)

Mythellaneous
Messenger Theatre Company
Sweet ECA
***

All great stories have much in common; great writers have borrowed from the Ancients, and each other. Most stories are pretty straightforward and similar. Love stories have the boy-meet-girl theme with the requisite obstacles thrown into the works to make for dramatic tension. All the greats have used this. Many of Shakespeare’s romances have more than one of this boy-meets-girl scenario.

Emily Davis and Jerry Richardson, with the assistance of Messenger Theatre Company out of New York, have set out to analyse the "hero" aspect of stories. And, although Jerry Richardson makes for a handsome if self-involved hero, it is Emily Davis who wins our hearts and souls. All of us who have been on the outside, longing to get in, can empathize with this hero, and without saying much at all. She has one of those faces, and talents, that say much. We see how she struggles to win the hero and to be the hero herself.

Mythellanous is well conceived and directed, if a little overworked and over-written at times. A good dramaturge and $40,000 could make this into a really fun, small off-Broadway show.

Catherine Lamm

Assassins
By Sephen Sondheim and John Weidman
Through The Window Theatre
C Central
***

Whoever said that there is a subject not appropriate to make into musical didn't talk to Stephen Sondheim or John Weidman. Together they created Assassins, a musical about historical characters who, for various different reasons, felt the need to assassinate the president of their time, or try. We get a unique take on the motivations of lone gunmen from John Wilkes Booth to John Hinckley. Assassins is not one of Sondheim's best or more frequently resurrected, but it too frequently seems to hold some relevancy. Maybe we should get him to add a character to this musical every couple of years.

A group of 12 performers from Through The Window Theatre, who have garnered some attention since their 2005 creation, have brought Assassins to the Fringe. Sondheim is not an easy or safe choice. Most of the cast are not great singers or actors but most of the group hold their own, helped in no small part by a group of solid musicians. Especially noteworthy is David Mouriquand's tortured attempt to understand the motivation of Lee Harvey Oswald. And we get an oddly sweet and even sympathetic John Hinckley from Thomas Chambers; not a safe choice but the right one. Ed Nightingale and James Clark keep the production nailed to the ground.

One should note here that playing historical characters is a minefield of weaknesses and missteps; especially the more contemporary ones who have been the focus of much television scrutiny. Kennedy's Children is a perfect example of when it works.

Many an acting teacher has stressed not playing a characteristic but the actor must justify motivations even if it leads away from what seems to be known about the celebrity. Squeaky Fromme, for example, wasn't crazy. We like to think that we send crazy people to institutions, not to jail. And Squeaky Fromme never thought she was crazy. Quirky, eccentric. She thought she made a lot of sense, had all the right answers and was completely justified.

Neil Robinson's direction is mostly clean, utilizing a relatively small space well. Tom Derham's lighting is serviceable but doesn't nail the tension and drama that better gunshots and sound from Booth's burning barn could bring to the production.

But high marks: a special morsel for Sondheim fans.

Catherine Lamm

Edges
A new musical by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul
Nimbus Theatre
C Central
*****

The programme illuminates the worthy support across the musical world. This is another in a long line of musical and plays which examines relationships; how and why they work...and when they don't. Edges is told exclusely through songs. Well, almost. There is a pair of videos totalling about 60 seconds (not necessary) and a sweet phone message which works better.

Edges is packed with funny, angry, and sad songs. It is superbly cast with strong actors with strong voices. Matt Woodgate and Jenny Bede show the foibles of the typically leading man and woman. Both Jenny Dawn and Christopher Finn nail the vulnerability and humour of being in and out of love. They all handle the funny and the sad in their own way. Jenny Dawn's "Better" shows off her comedic delivery and Christopher Finn's "I Once Knew" is heartbreaking; a song very unique in love stories.

A case might be made for developing the book to tie these characters into each other, a through-line, more of a story for the audience to sink their teeth in.

Although some of the songs are more universal, there is not a weak one in the bouquet. This is a show to see and a writing duo to watch.

Catherine Lamm

Next page - - - Index

 

 

©Peter Lathan 2008