British Theatre Guide logo
 
The Edinburgh Fringe

 

Links

Articles

News

Reviews

Amateur Theatre

Contact

Other Resources

 

 

Fringe 2009 Reviews (73)

The Man Who Planted Trees
By Jean Giono
Puppet State Theatre Company
Scottish Storytelling Centre
*****

This show has become a regular feature in the Fringe programme of the Scottish Storytelling Centre, selling out and winning awards for the last two years.

The show is based on Jean Giono's story about a poor shepherd in France who dedicated his life to planting thousands of trees in a fairly desolate area, completely transforming the landscape and the lives of the people who lived there, without ever seeking reward or recognition. Puppet State frames this with banter between storyteller Jean, played by Richard Medrington, and a puppet dog simply called Dog, operated and voiced by Rick Conte.

This wonderfully-moving story is told beautifully by Medrington with the aid of simple but nicely-designed props, puppets and sets by Ailie Cohen, who also directs, and an evocative soundscape from Barney Strachan. The audience even gets to experience the smells of the French countryside (nice ones) and a bit of mist and rain. The conversations between Jean and Dog that link the story together are superb bits of comic business that are absolutely hilarious for children and adults, with Medrington as the straight man to Dog's great gags.

This really is a show that appeals to all ages and is still a major highlight of the Fringe that can certainly withstand repeated viewings and still seem as fresh, funny and moving as ever.

David Chadderton

Adriano Adewale: Sound Journey
Created, composed and performed by Adriano Adewale
Augustines
***

Adriano Adewale has previously visited the Fringe as part of guitarist Antonio Forcione's quartet, filling a large part of the stage with his amazing array of percussive musical toys. Both have solo shows this year, but while Forcione is content with a conventional structure in which he introduces a series of numbers as he plays them, Adewale has created a music and movement piece in conjunction with movement director Kate Flatt and dramaturg Andrea de Almeida.

There are some elements that are recognisable from his shows with Forcione, such as his amazing tuned instrument made from plastic drain piping that he plays by hitting with a flip-flop, and the use of water dripping from a plastic bottle in an atmospheric piece about the rain forest. He gets some incredible sounds out of just a tambourine during one number, sounding like a whole percussion orchestra by himself, and there is a great piece in which he creates the sounds of three different characters. Other pieces are less successful or drag on a bit: his movement piece wearing a jacket covered in jangly bottle tops is initially interesting but quickly becomes repetitive.

Adewale is a very talented musician and has some unusual and fascinating pieces and instruments. His playful sense of humour that he has displayed sometimes in his concerts with Forcione only rarely is allowed to creep into this show which takes itself a little too seriously.

David Chadderton

The Fall of Man
Red Shift Theatre Company
Pleasance Courtyard
***

Milton's poetry is interspersed between scenes which chart and rise and fall of three things: an extra-marital relationship, the married guy's penis and his au pair's interest in him.

In a hectic fringe atmosphere, the experience of entering a theatre and seeing a woman asleep in a bed comes as something of a relief, but it is only the calm before the storm.

The first words break through the abrasively percussive score playing in the background: "Get out!" The story begins, as if in a flashback, although this is never really made clear. We see the couple's relationship develop, their lust fizzle out, their love, if ever it was present, escape, and we realise that all they were doing is trying to escape their humdrum existences – he trying to inject some life into his conventional marriage and job, and she trying to improve her lot in life.

The costume states the unstated – the suspense is never set up: we know what happened to Adam and Eve – why will this be anyy different? The strong stories – biblical and real life – work on their own terms. The marriage of Milton and the story of the Fall of Man doesn't. Or at least, I didn't get it. If he was Adam and she Eve, then what was the role of the man's wife (who never appears in the performance, but is a strong presence, nevertheless)? The male actor takes on the role of Satan at times, which also confuses things.

The connections are tenuous. "That first battle" comes after their first kiss. If it was a battle of conscience, then all I can say is Holloway buys into the predestination argument in this production. And if the characters having an affair are doing it as a means of escape, is the humdrum existence being likened to paradise? If so, I'd want to escape.

References to death in Milton's poetry are applied equally to her periods and his orgasm.

Satan lifts a light, and addresses it as heaven, then uses it to survey the terrain on which intends to deploy his forces – the lover's bed, colouring it with the same light, confusing the boundaries.

Adam's address to Eve, "Sole partner, and sole part, of all these joys …" in which Adam underlines the need to respect the one thing God has asked them not to do, in this context becomes an "ode to a buttock". Is the guy touting for anal sex? To quote Milton, "horrid confusion heaped upon confusion rose." In the garden of Eden, Eve gave Adam an apple to eat. In the production, the girl gave the guy a blow job. All was lost and death was given another reference point – ejaculation. Where have I heard that before?

"Wisdom which alone is truly fair" cannot have been part of the conceptual approach to this production which is confused and fails to hang together. The play ends, as it begun, by going full cycle. "Get out!" I obeyed. Willingly.

Leon Conrad

Next page - - - Index

 

 

©Peter Lathan 2009